Table of Contents
Bath & North East Somerset Local Plan 2025–2043
Representation from Temple Cloud with Cameley Parish Council
1. Introduction and summary of objection
This representation objects to the scale, location and proposed approach to development at Temple Cloud in the Bath & North East Somerset Local Plan 2025–2043.
The Parish Council recognises the need to provide housing and support sustainable development. The issue is not whether Temple Cloud can accommodate any additional development, but whether the scale of development under consideration has been demonstrated, on the evidence available, to be justified, effective, deliverable and consistent with the Plan’s spatial strategy and applicable national policy.
The Council’s options material identifies:
- a Temple Cloud site for 130 homes (policy 5.11)
The Rural Areas Topic Paper identifies baseline growth for Temple Cloud of approximately 30 dwellings, or 5%.
The relationship between these figures requires clear explanation. The proposed 130 dwellings is substantially above the stated baseline. The Council should explain precisely how the figures are treated in the housing supply calculations, spatial strategy and infrastructure assessment.
The Parish Council does not suggest that the baseline figure automatically constitutes a legally fixed development limit. It does, however, provide an important reference point against which the much larger potential scale of growth should be justified.
The central concern is that the evidence presently available to the Parish Council does not demonstrate that the proposed or contemplated scale of growth:
- is justified by the spatial strategy and housing evidence;
- can be accommodated by the A37 corridor and associated transport infrastructure;
- can be delivered without unacceptable air-quality, environmental or cumulative effects;
- is supported by sufficiently certain infrastructure capacity, funding and delivery arrangements; and
- is effective and deliverable in practice.
Requested modification: The large-scale Temple Cloud options should be removed or substantially reduced. Any retained development should be subject to an infrastructure-led, properly phased and evidence-based approach.
2. Is the scale of development justified?
2.1 Baseline growth and the larger options
The Rural Areas Topic Paper identifies baseline growth for Temple Cloud of approximately 30 dwellings, or 5%.
The subsequent options for 130 homes require a clear explanation of:
- whether the figures are alternatives, cumulative proposals or successive phases;
- whether they represent indicative capacities, potential allocations or longer-term development scenarios;
- which figures are relied upon for housing supply calculations;
- what transport, air-quality, infrastructure and environmental assumptions support each option; and
- how the options compare with reasonable alternatives elsewhere in the district.
The significant difference between the baseline and the potential options requires a proportionate, evidence-based justification. District-wide housing need does not, by itself, establish that a particular scale of development is justified at Temple Cloud.
Requested modification: The Plan should clearly identify the status and role of each Temple Cloud option and provide a clear evidential justification for any capacity substantially above the baseline.
2.2 Temple Cloud and the spatial strategy
Temple Cloud is a rural settlement on the A37 corridor. It is not identified in the material considered by the Parish Council as a Strategic Development Location.
The proposed scale of growth nevertheless appears strategic in character. The Council should therefore explain:
- why Temple Cloud is being considered for this level of growth;
- how the proposals fit the spatial strategy;
- how the scale relates to the characteristics of the settlement; and
- why the identified transport, service and environmental constraints can be overcome without relying on mitigation that is presently uncertain, unfunded or insufficiently developed.
If the spatial strategy treats another settlement, such as Clutton, as the strategic growth location while recognising constraints affecting Temple Cloud, the reasons for testing substantial strategic-scale development at Temple Cloud should be clearly explained.
Requested modification: Remove or reduce any Temple Cloud development capacity that cannot be justified through the published evidence base and an assessment of reasonable alternatives.
3. Is the development effective and deliverable?
3.1 Air quality and the A37 corridor
Air quality is a central constraint on development at Temple Cloud. The settlement is associated with an Air Quality Management Area and lies on the A37 corridor, where additional traffic could affect congestion, vehicle emissions and conditions experienced by residents.
On the evidence presently available to the Parish Council, it has not been demonstrated that the proposed scale of growth can be accommodated without unacceptable effects. The assessment should address:
- existing air-quality conditions;
- existing significant increases and queuing in traffic due to Bath and Bristol clean air zones;
- traffic flows, congestion and queuing;
- the effects of additional development traffic on the A37;
- the relationship between HGV movements, road geometry and local air quality;
- cumulative impacts from Temple Cloud and neighbouring settlements;
- the effectiveness, funding and timing of proposed mitigation; and
- monitoring and review arrangements.
General assumptions about future improvements in vehicle emissions or broad commitments to mitigation should not substitute for site-specific and corridor-specific assessment.
The Parish Council recognises that an AQMA does not automatically prohibit development. It does, however, make the scale, location, timing and mitigation of development particularly important.
Requested modification: Reconsider the proposed scale of Temple Cloud development unless the air-quality and transport evidence demonstrates that the effects can be acceptably managed. Any retained allocation should have specific mitigation, monitoring and review arrangements, with funding and delivery responsibilities identified where those measures are essential to the acceptability of development.
3.2 Transport, highway safety and corridor strategy
The A37 is the principal transport corridor serving Temple Cloud. The Parish Council is concerned about its capacity to accommodate substantial additional development, particularly in combination with growth in Clutton, Farmborough and other nearby settlements.
The relevant issues include:
- highway capacity and congestion;
- safety at junctions and site accesses;
- HGV movements and vehicle queuing;
- pedestrian and cycling safety;
- the quality and reliability of bus services;
- the deliverability of active-travel infrastructure; and
- the funding and implementation of bus priority or other corridor improvements.
On the evidence presently available to the Parish Council, it has not been demonstrated that proposed transport measures are sufficiently developed, funded and deliverable to support the scale of growth under consideration.
Requested modification: Complete a corridor-level transport and highway-safety assessment covering the relevant Temple Cloud development scenarios and cumulative growth in nearby settlements. The Plan should not rely on mitigation that remains conceptual, unfunded or otherwise undemonstrated as deliverable.
4. Cumulative development and infrastructure
The effects of development around Temple Cloud cannot be assessed solely by considering each settlement or site in isolation.
The Parish Council’s understanding of the options material is that potential development in Clutton and Farmborough could result in approximately 700 homes in the wider area, subject to the status and capacity of individual proposals being confirmed.
The Council should not assume that all such homes will use the same routes or infrastructure. Nevertheless, the proximity of the proposals and their potential relationship with the A37 mean that cumulative effects require proper consideration.
Relevant issues include:
- combined traffic and highway-safety impacts;
- air quality and congestion on the A37;
- clean air zones in Bath and Bristol pushing additional traffic onto the A37;
- pressure on primary and secondary education;
- healthcare demand;
- public-transport capacity and reliability;
- walking and cycling infrastructure;
- water, drainage and wastewater capacity;
- cumulative effects of construction and development timing; and
- the deliverability of the wider corridor strategy.
On the evidence presently available to the Parish Council, the cumulative impact of these proposals has not been demonstrated through a sufficiently comprehensive assessment.
Requested modification: Assess the combined effects of Temple Cloud, Clutton, Farmborough and other relevant nearby development proposals at the scale necessary to capture shared transport, environmental and infrastructure impacts. The findings should inform the final housing capacity, mitigation and phasing arrangements.
4.1 Healthcare
Temple Cloud is served by Cameley Surgery, understood to be a small rural GP practice with limited clinical space and staffing capacity.
The Parish Council is concerned that the capacity of existing healthcare provision to accommodate additional demand arising from the proposed scale of growth has not been demonstrated. In particular, the Plan should address:
- additional clinical staff;
- consulting and treatment rooms;
- expansion or relocation;
- funding and delivery responsibilities; and
- the timing of healthcare provision relative to housing occupation.
The Infrastructure Topic Paper’s treatment of the limited capacity of rural GP practices reinforces the need for site-specific evidence rather than an assumption that existing services can absorb significant growth.
Any estimates of additional GP staffing or clinical space should be verified by the relevant healthcare bodies and should not be treated as established without supporting evidence.
Requested modification: Incorporate specific healthcare capacity and delivery evidence for the proposed Temple Cloud growth, including identified funding, responsible bodies and appropriate infrastructure triggers.
4.2 Education and school transport
Cameley Primary School in Temple Cloud is understood to be small and site-constrained, with limited opportunities for expansion. Nearby primary schools, including those in Clutton and Farmborough, may also be affected by growth in the surrounding area.
Temple Cloud has no secondary school. The capacity and accessibility of receiving secondary schools therefore need to be considered, including travel arrangements and the cumulative effects of development in neighbouring settlements.
It is noted that the plan proposes a new primary school in Clutton, however the proposed route for children to school is along the A37. This road is not safe for children to walk along and the safety of this route will be significantly reduced with the increase in traffic from cumulative development. The Plan should identify safe access routes for children to new schools.
The Parish Council is also concerned about the adequacy and reliability of existing public transport for school children and residents. Recent service reductions have created circumstances in which public transport does not necessarily permit travel to nearby schools in time for the school day. Statutory school-transport arrangements do not provide services for all sixth-form pupils.
The Plan should therefore assess the actual transport services available, rather than relying on assumed future provision that has not been demonstrated to be deliverable.
Requested modification: Provide education-capacity and school-place planning evidence for the combined development scenarios, including primary and secondary provision, transport to receiving schools and the timing of any required expansion. Please include a proposal for safe walking routes to school that do not require walking along dangerous roads such as the A37.
4.3 Water and wastewater
Temple Cloud lies within the Paulton Water Recycling Centre catchment.
The Parish Council is concerned that the capacity of the wastewater system and the feasibility and timing of any required improvements have not been sufficiently demonstrated for the scale of growth under consideration.
The relevant infrastructure provider should establish:
- existing capacity and constraints;
- additional demand associated with the proposed growth;
- necessary improvements;
- funding and delivery responsibilities;
- timing of works relative to housing occupation; and
- any restrictions or triggers required to prevent premature development.
Requested modification: Include verified wastewater-capacity and deliverability evidence before relying on the proposed Temple Cloud development scale.
5. Environmental constraints, site selection and reasonable alternatives
5.1 Housing Development Boundary Review
The Parish Council understands that the Housing Development Boundary Review does not establish a case for major expansion of Temple Cloud or justify growth substantially beyond the stated baseline.
The boundary review should not be treated as the only relevant evidence. However, any departure from its findings requires a clear explanation supported by the wider evidence base.
Requested modification: Explain how the proposed site options relate to the boundary review and why development at the proposed scale is appropriate despite the settlement’s identified constraints.
5.2 Green space, landscape and ecology
The Parish Council is concerned that green spaces affected by potential development have not been assessed in sufficient detail in relation to landscape character, ecology, recreation and local amenity.
The assessment should establish:
- the location and function of relevant green spaces;
- landscape and ecological sensitivity;
- recreational value and existing community use;
- cumulative effects of development; and
- whether reasonable alternative sites or lower development capacities would avoid or reduce harm.
Requested modification: Ensure that green-space, landscape, ecological and recreational impacts are properly assessed before any Temple Cloud site capacity is relied upon.
5.3 Reasonable alternatives
The justification for the proposed scale of development should include a clear consideration of reasonable alternatives, including:
- lower development capacities at Temple Cloud;
- alternative sites or locations elsewhere in the district; and
- different spatial distributions of growth.
The Parish Council is particularly concerned that district-wide housing need should not be treated as sufficient justification for assigning a strategic scale of growth to a constrained rural settlement without demonstrating why reasonable alternatives have been rejected.
Requested modification: Publish or clearly identify the assessment of reasonable alternatives and explain how that assessment supports the proposed Temple Cloud capacity.
6. Sustainability Appraisal, consultation and legal compliance
The Parish Council requests that the Council and examining Inspector consider whether the Temple Cloud proposals meet the statutory requirements applicable to plan preparation, including requirements relating to sustainability appraisal and consultation.
The Parish Council’s concerns include whether the evidence base and Sustainability Appraisal adequately address:
- the Temple Cloud site options and different development capacities;
- air quality and the A37 corridor;
- infrastructure and healthcare capacity;
- primary and secondary education;
- cumulative impacts with Clutton, Farmborough and other relevant settlements;
- reasonable alternatives; and
- the relationship between Temple Cloud and the wider corridor strategy.
The Parish Council also seeks clarification regarding the consultation undertaken on the proposed scale of growth and its associated infrastructure implications. It is important to establish whether the relevant options, capacities and supporting evidence were made available for meaningful public consideration in accordance with the Council’s Statement of Community Involvement.
The Parish Council does not assert that a legal breach is established merely because it has not located a particular assessment or consultation document. If the relevant assessment or consultation has not been undertaken, or if applicable statutory requirements have not been met, the deficiency should be addressed before the Plan proceeds.
Requested modification: Review the Sustainability Appraisal, consultation record and supporting evidence for Temple Cloud and address any identified statutory or procedural deficiencies before submission or examination.
7. Soundness
The Parish Council considers that the Temple Cloud proposals raise concerns under each of the principal soundness considerations.
7.1 Positively prepared
The Plan should establish why the proposed Temple Cloud scale is required and how it contributes to the district’s housing strategy.
District-wide housing need should be distinguished from the evidence supporting the allocation of a particular scale of development at Temple Cloud.
Concern: The evidence presently available to the Parish Council does not demonstrate why Temple Cloud should accommodate the scale of growth under consideration rather than a lower capacity or a different distribution of growth.
7.2 Justified
The proposed scale should be supported by proportionate evidence relating to:
- transport;
- air quality;
- infrastructure;
- environmental constraints;
- settlement character; and
- reasonable alternatives.
The Parish Council is concerned that the proposed capacities have not been adequately reconciled with the constraints identified in the Council’s own evidence base.
Concern: Unless the Council can demonstrate that the proposed capacity follows from the evidence and from a proper assessment of reasonable alternatives, the justification for the scale of growth remains insufficient.
7.3 Effective
The proposals must be capable of being implemented in practice. Identifying potential mitigation is not sufficient where the measures necessary to make development acceptable remain uncertain.
Effectiveness requires, where relevant:
- clear delivery responsibilities;
- identified funding;
- realistic timescales;
- infrastructure triggers;
- monitoring arrangements; and
- mechanisms to respond if mitigation is ineffective or infrastructure capacity proves inadequate.
Concern: On the evidence presently available to the Parish Council, the deliverability of the infrastructure and mitigation necessary to support the proposed scale has not been demonstrated.
7.4 Consistent with national policy
The Plan should be assessed against the National Planning Policy Framework in force at the relevant stage of preparation and examination.
The NPPF was updated on 17 August 2026, replacing the previous December 2024 version. Earlier draft objections should therefore not rely on previous paragraph references without checking them against the Framework applicable at the relevant stage.
The Parish Council’s concerns relate in particular to national policy requirements concerning sustainable development, transport, healthy places, infrastructure, environmental effects and the preparation of justified and effective plans.
8. Required modifications
The Parish Council requests the following modifications.
8.1 Remove or reduce unsupported growth
- Remove Temple Cloud from large-scale strategic growth, or substantially reduce the proposed scale.
- Reconsider the 130-home option.
- Limit any retained growth to a proportionate level that reflects the settlement’s constraints and the evidence of deliverability.
The approximately 30-dwelling figure identified in the Rural Areas Topic Paper should be treated as a reference point for proportionality, not asserted as an automatic legal ceiling.
8.2 Complete the evidence necessary to demonstrate justification and deliverability
Before relying on any substantial Temple Cloud allocation, the Council should complete or publish, as appropriate:
- A37 corridor-level transport and highway-safety modelling.
- Air-quality assessment and mitigation evidence.
- Primary and secondary education-capacity evidence.
- Healthcare-capacity and delivery evidence.
- Water and wastewater-capacity evidence.
- Cumulative assessment covering relevant nearby development.
- Green-space, landscape and ecological assessment.
- Assessment of reasonable alternatives and different development capacities.
- Evidence demonstrating the deliverability of the proposed corridor strategy.
9. Infrastructure-led and phased development
If any development is retained at Temple Cloud, the Parish Council requests an infrastructure-led approach in which essential safety improvements and infrastructure provision precede substantial housing delivery.
The following is proposed as a planning approach rather than an assertion that a fixed five-year or 18-year programme is automatically required by law.
Phase 1 – infrastructure and safety
Before substantial housing delivery, the Council should establish and, where necessary, secure delivery of:
- A37 corridor and highway-safety improvements;
- effective air-quality mitigation;
- healthcare capacity planning and agreed delivery arrangements;
- primary-school capacity planning;
- a secondary-school access and transport strategy;
- walking and cycling infrastructure;
- secured public-transport funding and improvements; and
- verified wastewater capacity and required upgrades.
Where a measure is essential to the acceptability of development, it should have identified funding, a responsible delivery body, a realistic timescale and an appropriate delivery trigger.
Phase 2 – proportionate housing
If the necessary infrastructure measures have been delivered and their effectiveness demonstrated, any initial housing delivery should be limited to a proportionate level, potentially around the 30-dwelling baseline, subject to final evidence and infrastructure capacity.
This would prevent strategic-scale housing from being released before the consequences of earlier development can be evaluated.
Phase 3 – review and reassessment
Any further development should be subject to updated evidence, including:
- corridor-level transport modelling;
- air-quality modelling and monitoring;
- education and healthcare capacity assessments;
- wastewater and drainage capacity;
- review of cumulative development in neighbouring settlements; and
- assessment against the soundness requirements applicable at that stage.
Later phases should not proceed automatically if monitoring demonstrates that infrastructure is inadequate, mitigation is ineffective or environmental conditions have deteriorated.
10. Conclusion
The Parish Council recognises the need for housing and sustainable development. Its objection is to the scale and evidential basis of the growth being considered at Temple Cloud, rather than to the principle of all development.
The key issues are:
- the substantial difference between the stated baseline growth and the potential housing options;
- the constraints associated with the A37 corridor and air quality;
- the safety of access routes for primary school children walking to schools;
- the need for verified healthcare, education and wastewater capacity;
- the cumulative effects of development in Temple Cloud, Clutton, Farmborough and other nearby settlements;
- the need to reconcile the proposals with the Council’s spatial and corridor strategy;
- the adequacy of the Sustainability Appraisal, consultation process and assessment of reasonable alternatives; and
- the absence, on the evidence presently available to the Parish Council, of a sufficiently clear and deliverable infrastructure strategy for the proposed scale.
The Parish Council therefore requests that the large-scale Temple Cloud options be removed or substantially reduced.
If development is retained, it should be supported by:
- robust and proportionate evidence;
- corridor-level assessment of transport and cumulative impacts;
- effective air-quality and environmental safeguards;
- verified infrastructure capacity;
- identified funding and delivery responsibilities;
- appropriate infrastructure triggers;
- proportionate phasing; and
- monitoring and review mechanisms.
The Parish Council’s preferred outcome is a proportionate level of development that reflects Temple Cloud’s settlement characteristics, environmental constraints and infrastructure capacity. Any further growth should be contingent upon the delivery and demonstrated effectiveness of the infrastructure and mitigation required to support it.
The Plan should not rely on strategic-scale development at Temple Cloud unless that scale is demonstrably justified, effective, deliverable and consistent with the applicable statutory requirements and national planning policy.
- Posted: 29th October 2026
- Version: draft rev 2 – to be ratified 10th Nov 26
- Other vers: Local Plan 2026-10


